There's no place like Saturday...

July 12, 2012

College Football Report - Package Deals, a New Wave of Recruiting:

Making deals is a part of sports. They’re a contract business.

Professional sports are of course. College sports on the other hand, are an exception.

Or so they used to be.

In a decade long debate of whether or not college athletes, particularly football players, should be getting paid, the NCAA has refused to budge on the matter. There are loopholes, however.

Players may not be taking benefits from their prospective colleges, but they are taking advantage of their situation. In the case of
2013 No. 1 recruit Robert Nkemdiche, throwing his weight around, all 260-pounds of it, is exactly what he’s doing. 

Last week, Nkemdiche, a 6-foot-5, 270-pound defensive end and Clemson commit out of Loganville, Ga., stirred up debate when he told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution he might consider another school if Clemson did not offer a scholarship to Grayson High School teammate, Ryan Carter.

Clemson already has verbal commitments from Nkemdiche and Grayson teammates Wayme Gallman and David Kamara in their 2013 recruiting class. They've also granted a walk-on request to 2011
Grayson teammate Nick Schuessler, who signed with Mississippi State last fall.

Carter an un-ranked two-star defensive back has received offers from few Division I programs, among them Mississippi, Arkansas State, Tulane and East Carolina. Clemson, however, never appeared to be in the picture, until perhaps now.

Clemson head coach Dabo Swinney most likely took a second look at Ryan Carter when the report first surfaced, but if Carter, who had to have been in their scouting process before, with three of his teammates already committed, wasn’t good enough for a scholarship then, then it’s clear why the motive has changed.

Chad Simmons, national recruiting analyst for, recently shared his take on the situation with the New York Times.

“Robert’s in that catbird seat where he can almost call his shots. I guarantee Clemson is thinking right now, ‘Should we take Ryan Carter tomorrow just to lock in Nkemdiche?’”

Since the negative whiplash, Nkemdiche has said he’s firmly committed to Clemson even without Carter on board and that his comments were taken out of context. One has to wonder though, how far is too far in the recruiting game? Are two-for-one deals for high school teammates a sign of the future?

No matter how good, or how many starts the recruiting sites pour out, the line in the sand has to be drawn at some point by the school itself.

“I hope Clemson just keeps recruiting the players they planned to recruit,” Simmons told the Times. “If they have Ryan Carter somewhere on their board and they offer, that’s great, but I don’t think you want to start putting too much power in the kids’ hands.”

Nkemdiche isn’t the first big-time recruit to give a request to a college, though. Just last year, 2012 Miami Norland recruit, and the nation’s No. 7 ranked linebacker according to, Keith Brown, did just the same.

A longtime University of Miami commit with fellow teammates Randy “Duke” Johnson and Erik Flowers, Brown de-committed from the hometown Hurricanes because they refused to extend an offer to his brother and fellow linebacker, Lamar Atkins.

Brown and Atkins would later commit to Illinois, then under the direction of head coach Ron Zook. When Zook was fired, the offers to both players still stood, but Brown and Atkins would later sign with Louisville.

Louisville and Illinois ended up as Atkins only Division I offers, turning the situation into a clear, cut-and-dry package deal with Brown. 

Current Tennessee wideout Da'Rick Rodgers was involved in a package deal in 2010. Rodgers de-committed from Georgia because the Vols offered his high school teammate, Nash Nance. Rodgers has since gone on to stardom after a jail riddled two years, while Nance has since transferred to Division III Sydney College.

So called package deals have been around longer than most know. It’s only the obvious, like Brown’s deal, or the mainstream and public, like Nkemdiche’s, which get noticed. They offer a whole new set of politics to recruiting, and football in general, but only if coaches buy in to what the recruits are selling.

Carter may or may not end up at Clemson, but if he does, one has to wonder if the scholarship was truly earned. As long as top recruits hold the leverage in recruiting, though, package deals will continue to be a growing part of big-time college football.

July 9, 2012

College Football Reprot - College Football Playoff a Major Step for NCAA:

College football's Bowl Championship Series (BCS) has been called many names over its 14 years, worthy not being one of them. Come the end of the 2014 season, however, the BCS system becomes about as useful of a program as a Charlie Sheen self help book series.

On June 26, NCAA conference commissioners and an oversight committee, along with school presidents, passed a four-team seeded playoff system for college football, effective at the end of the 2014 college football season.

A four-team playoff system, or any playoff system in college football, is one giant step in the right direction in a sport where fans, writers, coaches and even US Congress members have been reaching out for a playoff for over two decades.

The plan is to have two semifinal bowl games, most likely on New Year’s Eve or New Year’s Day, with the National Championship a week later in hopes of creating a “Championship Monday.” The deal is setup to be in place for 12 years.

Most had been calling for something larger than a plus one model, but conference commissioners were reluctant to infringe on what many refer to the best regular season in sports.

Expanded playoffs in professional sports like baseball and football, along with an expanded postseason in college basketball, have diminished the pressures of their regular seasons.

A current plan on how the four teams will be selected is yet to be determined, but a selection committee, like that of college basketball’s postseason, has been discussed as an option. The semifinal bowl games will rotate between six traditional bowls, with almost a guarantee of the Rose, Sugar, Fiesta and Orange taking part.

The National Championship game will go to the city with the highest bid, creating a steady stream of increased revenue for the NCAA and college football conferences.

While it looks as if the four team playoff system should ease critics for now, fans calling for a larger playoff system will always exist. Nebraska Chancellor Harvey Perlman knows controversy is far from over.

“I don’t think any of us are naive to assume it ends the controversy. We’ll pick four teams and there’ll be a fifth.”
It’s hard to argue with Perlman, who along with everyone else knows there’s always going to be college basketball teams pleading their case, even in a 68 team field.
Obama has been all in favor of a playoff

One thing a four team playoff eliminates most importantly is the chance of an undefeated school being left out, like that of the 2004 Auburn Tigers. The Boise State’s and TCU’s of college football may have farther to go, however, as strength of schedule figures to weigh heavily.

If anyone can be happy the BCS kicked the bucket with an adapted playoff, it’s President Obama. The Commander In Chief campaigned for a playoff before he became president, claiming to “Throw my weight around a little bit.”

Its unlikely Obama’s weight was what broke the BCS system, but he does have one more promise kept to add to his next campaign.
All writing and views subject to © Drew P. Kochanny, All Rights Reserved. Photo's credited to rights owner.